The United States is now standing at a crucial crossroads in the effort to reform health care: more government control vs. greater choice and competition in an open marketplace. The ultimate decision is thus between competing visions of whether power in the health care marketplace should reside with individuals or with the government.
Clearly, the direction of the massive reforms being designed and debated is to provide far greater control, powers to tax, expenditures, and intervention to the government. Though well-intended – with the goal of achieving greater health, equity, consumer protection, cost-efficiency, and effectiveness of care – measures that expand government influence often achieve the opposite. Further, this path can also lead to harms that reach beyond the realm of economics or even that of health.
Choice and competition are of paramount importance in every dimension of health care – from health insurance, medical technology, treatment, the creation and use of medications, the daily work of health care organizations and physicians, to hospital administration, research, and, underlying all, the rights of individuals to make private decisions about their personal care. Further, consumer choice and competition deliver higher quality and lower prices in nearly every other area of the economy. Allowing choice and competition can do the same for health care.
The research and articles below provide detail analysis of how free market solutions can be applied to health care. Without a genuine free market – to instead allow a more centralized, politicized control of health spending decisions – health care costs will remain too high, the value of health insurance too inadequate, and the quality of health care too low.
Studies
- "Health-Status Insurance: How Markets Can Provide Health Security," by John H. Cochrane, Policy Analysis no. 633, February 18, 2009
- "A Better Way to Generate and Use Comparative-Effectiveness Research," by Michael F. Cannon, Policy Analysis no. 632, February 6, 2009
- "Does the Doctor Need a Boss?," by Arnold Kling and Michael F. Cannon, Briefing Paper no. 111, January 13, 2009
- "Medical Licensing: An Obstacle to Affordable, Quality Care," by Shirley Svorny, Policy Analysis no. 621, September 17, 2008
- "A Gift of Life Deserves Compensation: How to Increase Living Kidney Donation with Realistic Incentives," by Arthur Matas, Policy Analysis no. 604, November 7, 2007
Articles/Op-eds
- "Let Customers Control The Money And Market Will Cure Health Care," by Michael F. Cannon, Investor's Business Daily, July 16, 2009
- "Obama Doesn't Have the Only Prescription for Healthcare Reform," by Michael D. Tanner, Los Angeles Times, July 5, 2009
- "The Non-Debate over Non-Reform," by Arnold Kling, National Review (Online), June 24, 2009
- "Reform Must Empower the Consumers," by Michael D. Tanner, Roll Call, June 8, 2009
- "'Health Status Insurance' Provides Real Alternative To Universal Care," by John H. Cochrane, Investor's Business Daily, March 30, 2009
- "McCain's Plan Is Sound," by Michael F. Cannon, New York Post, October 9, 2008
- "Innovate to Cut Health Costs," by Shirley Svorny, Los Angeles Times, October 6, 2008
- "How to Fix Healthcare Delivery," by Arnold Kling, The American, June 17, 2008
- "Voters Send Mixed Messages on Health Care," by Michael D. Tanner, Orange County Register, June 13, 2008
- "Markets Beat Government on Medical Errors," by Michael F. Cannon and Alain Enthoven, American Spectator (Online), May 13, 2008
- "Congress Messing with Your HSA," by Michael F. Cannon, Orange County Register, May 12, 2008
- "Healthy McCain," by Michael F. Cannon, National Review (Online), May 8, 2008
- "McCain's Health Care Plan: Radical and Right," by Michael D. Tanner, Orange County Register, May 6, 2008
- "McCain's Plan Bests Obama's," by Michael D. Tanner, The Hill, April 15, 2008
- "The Cost's the Thing," by Michael D. Tanner, National Review, March 12, 2008
- "Free-Market Course," by Patrick Basham, National Review (Online), March 10, 2008
- "Friends Want Friends to Do Health Care," by Michael F. Cannon, National Review (Online), October 16, 2007
- "Well Treated: The Road to McMedicine," by Arnold Kling, TCSdaily.com, October 10, 2007
- "Fix Health Care by Making Americans Care About Costs," by Michael F. Cannon, USA Today, September 5, 2007
- "How to Cover Them," by Michael F. Cannon, New York Sun, August 28, 2007
- "The Universal Distraction," by Arnold Kling, TCSdaily.com, August 7, 2007
- "Debatable Assumptions," by Arnold Kling, TCSdaily.com, July 25, 2007
- "Let Go of the Status Quo," by Michael F. Cannon, New York Sun, July 6, 2007
- "Two Health Care Documentaries," by Arnold Kling, Washington Times, June 30, 2007
- "'Sicko' Health Care Reform," by Michael D. Tanner, Copley News Service, June 29, 2007
- "Michael Moore Goes Sicko on Health Care Reform," by Michael D. Tanner, Examiner.com, June 18, 2007
- "I'm Not Going to Pay a Lot for This MRI," by Michael F. Cannon, Weekly Standard, June 15, 2007
Podcasts
- "Choice, Competition Should Drive Health Care Reform" featuring Michael D. Tanner, July 15, 2009 [Flash Audio, 05:19]
- "Health Care: Fostering Focus Factories" featuring Regina Herzlinger, June 26, 2009 [Flash Audio, 08:43]
- "Ideas for Free-Market Health Care Reform" featuring Rep. Paul Ryan, June 19, 2009 [Flash Audio, 08:26]
- "Coordinated Care Versus Government" featuring Arnold Kling, January 26, 2009 [Flash Audio, 11:25]
- "Cutting Needless Health Care Spending" featuring Michael F. Cannon, February 25, 2009 [Flash Audio, 08:46]
- "Three Bad Health Reform Plans" featuring Michael D. Tanner, December 23, 2008 [Flash Audio, 05:51]
- "Would McCainCare Yield Coverage for John McCain?" featuring Michael F. Cannon, May 27, 2008 [Flash Audio, 06:06]
- "Wyden-Bennett Versus Healthcare Markets" featuring Michael F. Cannon, May 19, 2008 [Flash Audio, 07:02]
- "McCain Backs Markets, Deregulation in Health Care" featuring Michael D. Tanner, May 5, 2008 [Flash Audio, 07:01]
- "Pushing Parity for Mental Health" featuring Michael F. Cannon, March 24, 2008 [Flash Audio, 06:36]
- "The Tax Code and Large Health Savings Accounts" featuring Michael F. Cannon, March 17, 2008 [Flash Audio, 10:42]
- "McCain and Obama on Health Care" featuring Michael D. Tanner, February 25, 2008 [Flash Audio, 05:08]
- "State Health Insurance Mandates Raise Prices" featuring Michael F. Cannon, February 19, 2008 [Flash Audio, 07:03]
- "Regulation Blocks Convenience Clinics" featuring Michael F. Cannon, February 11, 2008 [Flash Audio, 08:07]
- "Cut Medicine in Half" featuring Robin Hanson, October 2, 2007 [Flash Audio, 07:36]
- "Counting the Uninsured" featuring Michael F. Cannon, September 4, 2007 [Flash Audio, 08:08]
- "Dr. POTUS" featuring Michael D. Tanner, August 30, 2007 [Flash Audio, 06:07]
- "The Anti-Universal Coverage Club" featuring Michael F. Cannon, July 20, 2007 [Flash Audio, 06:54]
- "Cost Insulation or Health Insurance?" featuring Arnold Kling, February 5, 2007 [Flash Audio, 08:39]
- "The President’s Healthcare Proposal" featuring Michael F. Cannon, January 24, 2007 [Flash Audio, 06:42]
Books
Send to friendPrinter-friendly version